Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
When an injured person later dies, North Dakota families can hold two separate claims. The wrongful death claim pays for what the family lost. The survival claim pays for what your loved one suffered before passing, such as medical bills, lost wages, and conscious pain and suffering.

Yes. North Dakota families can bring a wrongful death claim when an accident injury causes a death days, weeks, or months later. The law asks whether someone’s negligence caused the death, and it sets no cutoff for how long your loved one lived afterward. The injury also gave your loved one a second claim, which survives the death, for the losses suffered before passing. Our North Dakota wrongful death attorneys at Pringle & Herigstad, P.C. have served North Dakota families since 1909, and we can show you which claims your family holds and how long you have to act.

What the Law Looks at When a Death Comes Later

North Dakota’s wrongful death law asks what caused the death. A family can sue when a death is caused by a “wrongful act, neglect, or default” that would have let the injured person sue had they lived. Nothing in the law that lets families sue when negligence causes a death sets a time limit between the injury and the death. A driver who dies at the scene and a driver who dies three months after a car accident can both support a wrongful death claim. Your family has to prove that someone’s negligence caused the accident and that the injuries from the accident caused the death.

The North Dakota Supreme Court has seen this situation. In a 2002 case, a man was seriously injured when his vehicle collided with another driver’s. He was treated at a Grand Forks hospital, never regained consciousness, and died about two weeks later. The court held that his injury claim, including his medical bills, survived his death. His four children also pursued wrongful death claims for the loss of their father.

Your Family Can Hold Two Separate Claims

North Dakota recognizes two different claims when an injured person later dies. The Supreme Court has faulted a trial court for blending them, because each one pays for a different loss.

Here is how the two claims differ:

Wrongful Death Claim

This claim belongs to the family and pays for what the family lost. State law sets the order of who brings the claim, starting with the surviving spouse, then the children, then a parent. If the person first in line does not act within 30 days after a demand from the next person, that next person can file. The money goes to the heirs, and your loved one’s creditors cannot collect their debts from it. A hospital lien that attached before the death works differently, as explained below.

Survival Claim

Your loved one held this injury claim before dying. It continues after death as part of the estate. The estate pursues what your loved one could have recovered, such as the medical bills from the weeks of treatment, lost wages, and conscious pain and suffering.

In one case, the Supreme Court noted that the children could have sought the survival damages alongside their wrongful death claim. Bringing both claims lets your family seek payment for the losses before the death and the losses after it.

How Do You Prove the Accident Caused the Death?

In a delayed-death case, expect the defense to argue that something else caused the death. An insurer can point to an infection, a surgery, a fall in the hospital, or a health condition your loved one had before the crash. Your family needs a medical record that connects each step from the injury to the death.

The evidence that builds that connection includes:

  • The crash report and photos that show the force of the impact
  • Emergency room and hospital records from the first day forward
  • The death certificate and the cause of death it lists
  • Autopsy findings, when an autopsy was performed
  • Opinions from treating doctors or independent medical experts who explain how the injury led to death

Request these records early, while the doctors who treated your loved one still remember the details. If a commercial truck was involved, the carrier’s driver logs and maintenance records belong on that list too.

If you believe a hospital mistake contributed to the death, that part of the case follows separate rules. If the provider asks, a court must dismiss a lawsuit against a doctor, nurse, hospital, clinic, or nursing or assisted living facility without prejudice, meaning the dismissal is not a final ruling on the claim, unless the family serves a sworn expert opinion within three months after the lawsuit is started. The court can give more time if the family shows a good reason and asks before the three months end. The affidavit rule does not apply to obvious mistakes, such as a procedure on the wrong patient or body part, or an object left inside the patient.

For a death caused by malpractice, the two-year clock starts when the family knows, or reasonably should know, that a provider’s possible negligence caused the death. Even so, the lawsuit must start within six years after the malpractice, unless the provider’s fraud kept the family from discovering it.

What Compensation Is Available After a Delayed Death?

North Dakota law lists the losses a jury can award money for in a death or injury case. Economic damages cover medical care, rehabilitation, custodial care, lost earnings, loss of support, burial costs, and the cost of replacing household services. Noneconomic damages cover pain, suffering, mental anguish, emotional distress, and loss of society and companionship.

Each claim draws on that list for a different person’s losses. The survival claim seeks what your loved one could have recovered, such as the medical bills, and conscious pain and suffering. The wrongful death claim covers what the family lost. In a 2008 decision, the Supreme Court confirmed that a parent’s children can seek damages for their mental anguish and lost companionship.

Families also need to know about hospital liens. A North Dakota hospital that treats an accident victim can file a lien, which is a legal right to be paid the reasonable value of its hospital services out of the at-fault driver’s insurance or a settlement. In the 2002 case, the hospitals were paid from the driver’s $100,000 policy before the children divided what remained. The court also noted that the heirs could still pursue the at-fault driver for the rest of their damages. When the at-fault driver’s policy is small, the hospital bills can take a large share of it, so your lawyer should look for every other source of coverage.

When the Two-Year Deadline Starts

State law gives families two years to start a wrongful death lawsuit, and the two-year clock starts on the date of death. In North Dakota, a lawsuit starts when the summons is served on the defendant, so a family must serve the summons before the two years end. The family can also meet the deadline by delivering the summons for service to the sheriff of the correct county before the two years end, if the summons is then served or first published within 60 days. If a state agency or state employee may be at fault, a written notice to the state may be due well before the two years end.

If your loved one died eight months after the accident, your family has two years from that death. The Supreme Court enforced the rule in 1980, when it barred a widow’s claim brought nearly four years after her husband died from a farm painting injury. When a family member entitled to bring the claim is a minor or has certain other legal disabilities, the family may have more time, but have a lawyer confirm the date.

The survival claim runs on a different clock. The Supreme Court has explained that it arose on the day of the injury, when your loved one first could have sued. If your loved one died before the deadline for that injury claim ran out, the estate’s representatives have at least one year from the death to bring it. Ask a lawyer to confirm that deadline early, because it is counted from the day of the injury.

The two claims run on separate clocks, and a family that waits until the estate is settled can miss one of the deadlines. Talk with a lawyer about both deadlines as soon as you can.

Talk With a North Dakota Wrongful Death Attorney

Your family held on to hope through every day of treatment, and you should not have to sort out estates, liens, and deadlines alone. Pringle & Herigstad, P.C. has served North Dakota families since 1909 from offices in Grand Forks and Minot. Contact us for a free consultation. We work on contingency, so you owe no attorney fee unless we recover for you.